ISCAST Fellow Samuel McKee was deeply unimpressed by this book, edited by J.P. Moreland, Stephen C. Meyer, Christopher Shaw, Ann K. Gauger, and Wayne Grudem.
McKee says the book claims to offer a scientific critique of theistic evolution, but “there is no science at all from the very beginning.”
I have little good to say about this book, mostly because the book itself has almost nothing scientific to say. Anyone that has read a scientific paper or text before in school, college or research expects data, information presented clearly, and scientific analysis. Despite the promises in the preface and introductory chapters, there is no science at all from the very beginning. Given my experience reading the ID works, my expectations were already low for the scientific content (both its volume and truth) but even then I was shocked by the complete absence of science.
More From the Journal
